to top 10 table

Best Board Shorts for Water Exercises Reviewed

last updated Jun 14, 2019

As a combat fighter, best board shorts are a must. When you are sparring or grappling, there needs to be a layer of cloth between yourself and your opponent. These shorts are ideal as they are slightly longer than knee length, meaning that they can give you a little more protection while keeping your legs cool. Board shorts are also great as many combat athletes enjoy swimming a form of cardio. Depending on how you time your workouts, many fitness centers have areas where you can build your muscles and also have a pool you can hop into afterwards.

In a Hurry? The test winner after 4 hrs of research

icon
Alki'i Men's Hybrid Board Shorts
99.8/100 our score
Drainage
100
Fit
100
Effectiveness
100
Materials
99
Ease of Use
100
Alki'i Men's Hybrid Board Shorts
Why is it better?

Comfortable and secure

A grade shorts

Well made

High quality material

Multiple pockets

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
Alki'i Men's Hybrid Board Shorts
Test Winner: Alki'i Men's Hybrid Board Shorts
Amazon Link
Researched Sources
2
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
1952
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
4
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
10
Products Evaluated
Sorting Options
Drainage Fit Effectiveness Materials Ease of Use By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
#1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
99.8
Drainage
100 %
Fit
100 %
Effectiveness
100 %
Materials
99 %
Ease of Use
100 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$16.99
#2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
97.6
Drainage
99 %
Fit
97 %
Effectiveness
98 %
Materials
97 %
Ease of Use
97 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$18.99
#3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95
Drainage
95 %
Fit
96 %
Effectiveness
94 %
Materials
95 %
Ease of Use
95 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$18.99
#4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.2
Drainage
90 %
Fit
93 %
Effectiveness
92 %
Materials
90 %
Ease of Use
91 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$16.99
#5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.8
Drainage
87 %
Fit
88 %
Effectiveness
89 %
Materials
87 %
Ease of Use
88 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$36.99
#6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
84.8
Drainage
90 %
Fit
86 %
Effectiveness
75 %
Materials
81 %
Ease of Use
92 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$17.99
#7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
80.8
Drainage
88 %
Fit
86 %
Effectiveness
75 %
Materials
65 %
Ease of Use
90 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$34.99
#8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
78.2
Drainage
79 %
Fit
78 %
Effectiveness
78 %
Materials
77 %
Ease of Use
79 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$18.99
#9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
75.2
Drainage
76 %
Fit
75 %
Effectiveness
74 %
Materials
77 %
Ease of Use
74 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
#10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
73
Drainage
74 %
Fit
73 %
Effectiveness
75 %
Materials
72 %
Ease of Use
71 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (17.09.19)
Amazon Link
$28.00

Top 10 Picks

1. Alki'i Men's Hybrid Board Shorts

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
99.8
Alki'i Men's Hybrid Boardshorts with mesh Lining
Amazon Link
Drainage
100
Fit
100
Effectiveness
100
Materials
99
Ease of Use
100
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$16.99
Pros:

Comfortable and secure

A grade shorts

Well made

High quality material

Multiple pockets

Cons:

Sizes run big, purchase a size smaller

This is an incredibly comfortable pair of board shorts. Every part of the construction and design process was well thought out to ensure the ergonomics of the shorts. There is a lining within the shorts to give an extra sense of security and stability from inside out. It also comes with a drawstring enclosure which allows you to control how tight or loose you want to wear your shorts. In the event the drawstring fails, there is also a strong elastic to keep your pants up.

Read more

There is usually some form of water involved when you are using these shorts whether it is a swimming pool, lake, or ocean. During these times it is necessary to have a little extra protection of your sensitive areas. This particular product has a netting lining inside to add an additional layer to prevent invasive things from accidentally getting too close. It can also work to help give your groin area additional support, thus comfort.

It can be quite stressful to purchase products online as you cannot tell what their real size is. Depending on what you select, the pants you bought may not fit at all. To prevent you from having a product you cannot use at all, this product is constructed with an elastic waistband. This allows you to be a little bigger or smaller than the actual product as the elastic will secure the shorts in the correct place.

2. MaaMgic Swim Shorts

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
97.6
MaaMgic Mens Slim Fit Quick Dry Swim Shorts Swim Trunks Mens Bathing Suits with Mesh Lining
Amazon Link
Drainage
99
Fit
97
Effectiveness
98
Materials
97
Ease of Use
97
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$18.99
Pros:

Large selection of patterns

Unique designs

Very affordable

Slim fit

Quick dry material

Cons:

A little tight in the groin area

A very important factor of board shorts as how well they look on you. Sometimes it is important to stand out and look unique against every person that’s also at the beach or pool. This particular product comes with over thirty completely unique and different patterns and designs, so you don’t have to worry about clashing with someone else. All designs have different color themes, guaranteeing you will find one that you really like.

Read more

It can be incredibly frustrating for people who are on the skinnier side to purchase clothing products online. This is simply because most clothing articles are made to the average body size of a person and if you are skinnier, it is almost a guarantee it will not fit. This is a great solution for people with small hips as they are made to be slim fit. There is a slight tapering on the side, allowing the product to rest snugly and comfortably on your hips.

There are many occasions in which board shorts can be worn. The only unfortunate factor is that sometimes these occasions do not allow you to get out of your wet clothes right away. For instance, having a beach or pool party will mean you are in and out of the water multiple times.

To prevent you from walking around in soggy pants, this product is created with a quick dry material that significantly reduces the amount of time it takes to dry. This will allow you to enjoy whatever you are doing in a comfortable and stress-free manner.

3. Nonwe Beachwear

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95
Nonwe Men's Solid Lightweight Beach Shorts Half Pants with Lining
Amazon Link
Drainage
95
Fit
96
Effectiveness
94
Materials
95
Ease of Use
95
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$18.99
Pros:

Comfortable and secure

Multiple colors

Large variety of sizes

Very affordable

Inner lining

Cons:

No fly access

If you are looking for a pair of board shorts that are simple and work well, then look no further. This product comes in over fifteen different colors, but are one single color. This will allow you to stand out, but not completely announce your individuality. All of them come with deep pockets that also have a secure closure on top, eliminating your worry of losing anything. It also comes with a lining inside which can work to prevent unknown objects from entering the shorts.

Read more

Most people do not prefer to put things into their pockets when playing in the water with their board shorts. The buoyancy in the water can cause whatever is in your pocket to float out and come loose. This can be quite the disaster, especially if what you had was valuable. To minimize the number of things coming loose, this product has a flap on top of the pocket that can be secured with velcro. This will give a bit of extra production for the items in your pockets and prevent you from losing it.

One of the most uncomfortable feelings is for your groin area to feel exposed or loose. This can especially be a problem for males as there can be a significant weight in the area. Over a long period of time of free hanging, it can cause the muscles to become sore. This particular product comes with an inner lining that allows for your groin to be comfortably supported in a smaller and more enclosed environment. This can give you an additional sense of comfort and security.

4. VBRANDED

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.2
VBRANDED Board Shorts
Amazon Link
Drainage
90
Fit
93
Effectiveness
92
Materials
90
Ease of Use
91
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$16.99
Pros:

Quick dry technology

Durable material

Drawstring enclosure

100% polyester

Stylish and classy

Cons:

A little more expensive

This product is ideal and works well in all settings that require board shorts. Most people prefer wearing them at a barbeque or beach party, but these shorts hold up really well in the water. In the event you get them wet or spill something on them, they have a quick dry technology that you can simply shake off the moisture and reduce the time it takes to completely dry. It also comes with a drawstring enclosure, allowing the product to be fully customizable.

Read more

One of the most important things that any product can be is durable. Having a long lifespan allows people to use it for long periods but also develop a feeling of whether that product is worth it or not. This particular product is designed to last a long time. It is made with one hundred percent Polyester, which is one of the most durable fabrics on the market. It is made to be tough and can fight the effects of sand and salt water.

Wearing wet clothes for a prolonged period can increase the chances of catching a cold. This goes for when you are wearing board shorts as well. The moisture can greatly decrease your body temperature, allowing for germs and bacteria to infect you more easily. To prevent that from happening, this product uses quick dry technology that allows the board shorts to dry sooner. This will decrease the amount of time you are wandering around wet and uncomfortable.

5. O'Neill Loaded Hybrid

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.8
O'Neill Loaded Hybrid Board Shorts
Amazon Link
Drainage
87
Fit
88
Effectiveness
89
Materials
87
Ease of Use
88
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$36.99
Pros:

Zipper closure

Subtle elastic waistband

Khaki look

Durable and secure

Machine washable

Cons:

Much more expensive

This product is unique and stands out as it is incredibly sophisticated looking. Without touching the actual material, most people would not realize they are board shorts. They come with a clean look and was constructed to resemble khaki material. This allows the product to be worn in all sorts of settings. Coupled with the great seamsmanship, this is a product that you should really put consideration into purchasing.

Read more

There are many pants which have zipper closures and over time people have become used to them. When boardshorts do not have them, it can cause a slight inconvenience as you have to pull down the pants when you need to go to the bathroom. This can be especially troublesome for males as this would require a trip into a stall. This pair of shorts comes with a full zipper enclosure so that people who need to use it have it available.

If you have not changed after going to a barbeque or beach party, it can be quite noticeable as board shorts have a certain look to them. However, sometimes situations dictate it so that you cannot go home or change right away. This particular pair of pants have a wonderful design that makes them look like khakis. They can also be worn as casual clothing apparel on particularly hot summer days without looking out of place.

6. Nonwe Quick Dry

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
84.8
Nonwe Quick Dry board shorts
Amazon Link
Drainage
90
Fit
86
Effectiveness
75
Materials
81
Ease of Use
92
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$17.99
Pros:

Great design

Multiple colors

Large array of sizes

High quality material

Rip resistant

Cons:

Runs small, order one size up

This is a fantastic product that has a wonderful color scheme. There are over thirty different color designs to choose from and unlike any other pants, they actually have a theme. Every pair uses a different set of colors to create a gradient, with most of them including at least one bright color. It also comes in a large array of sizes, ensuring there is one that will fit you for sure. Depending on what you like, there are some designs that are more subtle than others. All in all, you will find something that will suit your liking.

Read more

It can be incredibly frustrating to purchase something to realize that it is a little off in the fitting. Rather than getting it tailored, most people will choose the option of purchasing a new product. This can be both wasteful and environmentally unfriendly. To prevent an incorrect fit, this product comes with a drawstring on the top of the elastic waist. This means you can adjust them specifically to a fit that makes it comfortable for you to wear.

Most people who have worn board shorts can attest to the fact that the material does not feel that comfortable. After wearing them for a long period of time, the material becomes scratchy and stiff. They also make a crinkling and swishing noise when you move around. This product was made with a specific fabric that is softer, which reduces the amount of itchy feeling you get. This means that you can wear them for a longer period of time and still be in comfort.

7. O'Neill Catalina

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
80.8
O'Neill Catalina Board Shorts
Amazon Link
Drainage
88
Fit
86
Effectiveness
75
Materials
65
Ease of Use
90
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$34.99
Pros:

Good ventilation

Elongated lifespan

Durable and secure

High quality material

Great design

Cons:

Fabric is a little thin

This product comes in a wide variety of colors and sizes, ensuring there is something right for everyone. This product is made from high-quality material that is durable and rip resistant. This is important as it will reduce the frequency of your replacements. The product has an elongated lifespan even after being machine safe. This product can hold its own very well in salt water and the seams were made in a way which it will be comfortable and irritant-free for the users.

Read more

One of the most underrated things that people often do not consider is the seams of the pants. Depending on how they are made, it can cause a lot of skin irritation. To prevent unnecessary rashes and discomfort, this product uses a flat seam sewing technique. Two pieces of fabric are overlapped and sewed rather than sewed where the connection point is. This eliminates any raised fabric within the board shorts, ensuring that it is seamless throughout the entire trunk.

As mentioned previously, it is important for board shorts to be able to dry quickly. This product uses a ventilation technique that allows for positive air transfer. There are tiny holes within the shorts that allow for air to easily transfer in and out. The movement of air can carry away the moisture within your pants, thus reducing the amount of time it takes to dry. It can also work well to keep your groin area fresh and odor free.

8. APTRO

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
78.2
APTRO Board Shorts
Amazon Link
Drainage
79
Fit
78
Effectiveness
78
Materials
77
Ease of Use
79
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$18.99
Pros:

Stretch fabric

Quick dry shorts

Multiple pockets

Very affordable

Great designs

Cons:

A little on the small side, order one size up

This brand has taken the time to create a design that works well for people. This particular item has side pockets that allow quick access to small items. If you plan to swim with your items and are looking for a way to secure them, there are back pockets on these shorts that have a velcro enclosure. There is so much technology behind these shorts, it’s surprising they were able to keep the cost so affordable.

Read more

Despite board shorts being long and loose, you would be surprised how important the need for the fabric to stretch is. If the fabric is inflexible, you won’t be able to bend or swim properly. This particular product is made with a fabric that stretches in all your ways, meaning that they won’t rip or tear regardless of which direction you move. This allows for a longer lifespan on your product.

There have been many instances where people have come out from playing in the water with pockets full of water. Usually, you have to spend a few minutes wringing them out or dumping the water out. This particular product comes with an ability for the pockets to self-drain. There is a small opening that is reinforced by metal that allows the water to leave your pocket, which saves you both time and embarrassment from looking silly.

9. Huk

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
75.2
Huk Board Shorts
Amazon Link
Drainage
76
Fit
75
Effectiveness
74
Materials
77
Ease of Use
74
best offer for today
Amazon Link
Pros:

Breathable fabric

Sturdy material

Zipper enclosure

Multiple use

Variety of colors

Cons:

Expensive

These shorts are wonderfully designed and something that everyone should consider investing in. Although they look like your typical pair of shorts, they come jam-packed with technology. They are made with tough woven fabric that is not easily torn or ripped apart. These shorts are not flashy and come in solid and subtle colors, making them perfect for any occasion.

Read more

When people are out and enjoying themselves, they want to be able to easily access everything. To prevent frustration or any accidental tearing of these shorts, all enclosures are made with zippers. There are multiple pockets on this product, all that is accessible via zipper. For people that use stand up urinals, there is also a zipper for easy access. This eliminates the frustration of trying to button or tie something up properly.

People use board shorts for many reasons, which may not necessarily include being in the water. During these times it is important for the shorts to be able to ventile and breathe properly otherwise you may be in for an uncomfortable experience. This particular pair of shorts are made with woven fabric, meaning that there are tiny holes where the heat can escape. This can encourage positive airflow and allow cool air to enter while the heat leaves.

10. Hurley One and Only 2.0

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
73
Hurley One and Only 2.0 Board Shorts
Amazon Link
Drainage
74
Fit
73
Effectiveness
75
Materials
72
Ease of Use
71
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$28.00
Pros:

100% polyester

Threaded closure

High quality fabric

Tough and durable

Multiple colors

Cons:

Material feels very thin

Hurley is a brand that is well known for its athletic apparel. They manufacture products that are tough, durable, and meant to last. This product is no different and will work well to serve their purpose. These shorts offer multiple layers of security to keep them in place and prevent them from moving. It also comes in over thirty colors and a large range of sizes, guaranteeing you will find something you like.

Read more

There are many similar products that use a drawstring enclosure. This is simply a string that goes around the waist and tied in a bow at the front. However, if you are swimming in the water the currents can accidentally loosen your tie.

To prevent that from happening, these shorts come with a threaded enclosure. Similar to a pair of shoes, the string has to criss-cross through a few holes before it can come undone. This allows a bit better security in the water.

After a long day out, all most people want to do is go home and relax. However, your gear can start to smell if it is not cleaned right away. This particular pair of pants are machine washable, which can do so much in saving time. Simply pop them into your washer and forget about them. Because they are made with polyester, these shorts will not wrinkle or shrink when being machine washed.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Drainage

When picking out a pair it is crucial to find something that can quickly dry. If not, you will be walking around with damp pants on which can be quite uncomfortable. For people with sensitive skin, the moisture can cause a reaction and cause your skin to rash up. Since the creation of quick-dry fabrics, much outdoor clothing has switched over. Because the materials dry quickly, it makes it much more convenient to wear.

For people who plan on spending all day at a beach or barbeque, it makes sense to purchase something that can dry quickly when you get out of the water. This will prevent you from making a mess and wander around in your soggy pants. It also is a much more comfortable wear. Despite most products being quick to dry, you should always double check before you purchase. Quick dry materials are usually a synthetic type of fabric such as nylon or polyester. Be careful when choosing as some of them may contain woven fabric, which will slow down the speed at which your clothing can dry.

Fit

Another thing to take into consideration when purchasing a pair is the length of them. There are some items on the market that are significantly shorter while others come up to knee length. Depending on how you use them, the length may make a whole world of difference. If you often incorporate swimming into your workout, it is recommended that you purchase something that is slightly shorter.

This will allow you to move your legs freely and without worry that they become tangled in the fabrics. If most of your time is going to be spent on dry land with occasional dips in the water, a longer length product that gets close to the knees may be suitable. For people who plan on sparring and grappling, it is important to purchase the longest lengths on the market. These will protect you from injuries and the sun.

Effectiveness

There are many different types of enclosures. The key is to find one that you find most comfortable and easy to use. Most are created with a drawstring enclosure. The products themselves have a strong elastic waistband to keep them roughly around your hips.

The string is then threaded behind the elastic so that you can tighten them to exactly where you want them on your body. This is an ideal enclosure as it gives you a perfect fit every time. Another type of enclosure is a button up.

These can become frustrating to use as it requires extra time to fit the button through the hole. This is usually not an issue when you are initially putting them on, but can become a problem when you are cold and shivering coming out of the water.

Most people prefer a zipper enclosure as it is the most streamlined and looks the nicest. The downfall of using them is that zippers tend to rust and become very brittle when they come in contact with the salt water. A final type of closure that is available is the hook and loop enclosure, which is commonly known as Velcro.

Materials

When you are choosing a pair, it is important to know what materials the product is made of. Avoid products made of cotton because this fabric is notorious for absorbing water. When cotton absorbs water, it also becomes incredibly heavy and hard to wear. It is very uncomfortable and will often increase your fatigue. Wearing something made of cotton will quickly tire you out and prevent you from training as long.

The ideal fabric used would be polyester. The perfect mixture would be a Polyester and Nylon blend, however, that is hard to come by. Many designs will use some sort of polyester in their clothing. Polyester is known for being able to dry quickly as the fabric does not retain a lot of water. This is ideal if you plan on going into a pool or ocean as the water will evaporate quickly.

Polyester is also resistant to wrinkling, meaning you don't have to worry about ironing. It also prevents you from getting the rumpled and waterlogged look when you come out of the water. The greatest factor about polyester is how durable it is. For athletes who may be training, it is necessary to be able to purchase something that is not going to rip easily. Polyester is made to take a tough beating and is rip resistant. This greatly improves the lifespan of your product.

Ease of Use

There are many small little things to take note when you are purchasing board shorts. One of them is:
What kind of closure would you like? Most manufacturers chose to use a Velcro closing as they are very easy and affordable to make. The material to create a Velcro closure is the most inexpensive way to increase the profit margin for a company.

This does not mean that it will only benefit the manufacturer and not the consumer. A Velcro closure can be quite handy when you are tired or under the influence. It is also very convenient as a slight tug will undo them. However, this may not be an idea for people who are looking for a little more security.

For people who are wanting to ensure their pants are secured. Some of them are made with button closure. However, this is not ideal because the salt water can eat away at the threading very easily. This will greatly shorten the life span of your clothing or require you to spend time affixing the button back on. Another alternative closure is a zipper.

These are ideal closures as they ensure your clothing will stay securely. However, the chlorine in pools and the salt water in the ocean can be incredibly damaging to a zipper. If they are not maintained properly, the metal will rust and render the zipper unzippable.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
#1
ico Drainage
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#2
ico Fit
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#3
ico Effectiveness
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#4
ico Materials
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#5
ico Ease of Use
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
expert tips icon
Sand Fights

Recently combat fighters have started to enjoy a new way of training, which is to spar on the beach. The sand is soft enough that should you fall or get pressed down, it will not cause an injury. At the same time, the sand also offers more resistance against your moving and spinning which can work to train your stamina and endurance. When you and your partner become too hot, simply hop into the ocean to cool off. If you are someone that is interested in partaking in this sort of training, then board shorts are a must.

Recovery Mode

These types of shorts are also ideal because most fitness centers have a sauna or steam room which you can use to relax your muscles after a workout. While building muscle is important, the recovery part is just as crucial. The lack of recovery time or plan for your muscles can cause them to cramp and become incredibly sore. If these pains are not rectified, it could cause damage to your muscles and also leave you in a lot of discomfort. Wearing a pair of boardshorts save you time from needing to change between your workout and entering the sauna or steam room.

Other Factors to Consider

Bottom Line

Board shorts are a great product as they are so multifaceted and can be used on many occasions. Depending on your likes and dislikes, they can look very trendy and stylish or be a simple workhorse product. Since their inception, they have evolved to become better as each season passes. It is surprising to think that these surfer jams have only been around for less than fifty years. This means that there are many people that still remember clearly what they wore prior to the creation of these shorts!

Frequently Asked Questions

q: Are you supposed to wear anything underneath boardshorts?

a:

The answer is no, but if you want to wear something underneath there is room to do so.

q: Where can I purchase board shorts?

a:

Most sports warehouses have them and so do supermarkets. However, it is recommended you purchase from an online retailer as there are more options.

q: How do you maintain a pair of board shorts?

a:

Board shorts are incredibly low maintenance and can be put in the washer and dryer to be machine washed.

q: Can I swim in board shorts?

a:

Absolutely! Many people wear board shorts to go to swimming pools. However, if you are a competitive swimmer, board shorts are not recommended as they are not very hydrodynamic.

q: Can females wear board shorts?

a:

Of course! Board shorts are not gender based and can be worn by anyone of any gender and age.

Sources

  1. Shawn Forno, Quick Dry Fabrics, Informational
  2. Swimoutlet Staff, Understanding Board Shorts, Informational