to top 10 table

Best Broken Toe Wraps Reviewed

last updated Aug 20, 2019

These broken toe wraps are something that everyone should have in their household, in a first-aid kit or in their gym bag. If you are an athlete or practice sports on a daily basis, these will be a godsend in various situations.

They are great at alleviating pain and treating all sorts of injuries, sprains, and strains. There are different kinds out there on the market and we tried to bring you one of the best and most comfortable ones, at very affordable prices.

Your usual broken toe wraps will be in the shape of a tape that is very thin and easy to wrap around toes and fingers. They can also be used for wrapping any other part of your body. This versatility is what gives them great value and applicability. You can not go wrong in choosing any of the wraps from our list.

In a Hurry? The test winner after 7 hrs of research

icon
California Basics
99.6/100 our score
Application
100
Breathability
100
Compression
99
Effectiveness
99
Protection
100
California Basics
Why is it better?

Self-adhesive

No clips

Does not stick to skin

Breathable

Affordable

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
California Basics
Test Winner: California Basics
Amazon Link
Researched Sources
30
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
9.8k
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
7
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
10
Products Evaluated
Sorting Options
Application Breathability Compression Effectiveness Protection By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
#1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
99.6
Application
100 %
Breathability
100 %
Compression
99 %
Effectiveness
99 %
Protection
100 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.09.19)
Amazon Link
$14.95
#2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
98.2
Application
98 %
Breathability
97 %
Compression
99 %
Effectiveness
99 %
Protection
98 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.09.19)
Amazon Link
$9.99
#3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
98
Application
99 %
Breathability
98 %
Compression
98 %
Effectiveness
98 %
Protection
97 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.09.19)
Amazon Link
$8.99
#4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96.8
Application
97 %
Breathability
96 %
Compression
97 %
Effectiveness
98 %
Protection
96 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.09.19)
Amazon Link
$9.99
#5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96.2
Application
96 %
Breathability
95 %
Compression
97 %
Effectiveness
97 %
Protection
96 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.09.19)
Amazon Link
$13.20
#6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.4
Application
95 %
Breathability
93 %
Compression
95 %
Effectiveness
94 %
Protection
95 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.09.19)
Amazon Link
$7.90
#7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94
Application
95 %
Breathability
94 %
Compression
93 %
Effectiveness
94 %
Protection
94 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.09.19)
Amazon Link
$15.50
#8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93
Application
92 %
Breathability
93 %
Compression
94 %
Effectiveness
93 %
Protection
93 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.09.19)
Amazon Link
$8.97
#9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92
Application
92 %
Breathability
91 %
Compression
93 %
Effectiveness
92 %
Protection
92 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.09.19)
Amazon Link
$15.99
#10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.6
Application
93 %
Breathability
91 %
Compression
92 %
Effectiveness
91 %
Protection
91 %
Price Comparison Last Updated (19.09.19)
Amazon Link
$24.95

Top 10 Best Broken Toe Wraps

1. California Basics

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
99.6
California Basics Broken Toe Wraps
Amazon Link
Application
100
Breathability
100
Compression
99
Effectiveness
99
Protection
100
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$14.95
Pros:

Self-adhesive

No clips

Does not stick to skin

Breathable

Affordable

Cons:

Stretches quickly

California Basics brings you an amazing adhesive tape that is a godsend to every athlete out there. It has numerous uses and can be wrapped around any part of your body that needs it. It is self-adherent, which means that it is able to stick to itself and not to your skin. We all know how uncomfortable that can be, especially when we need to wrap something that is painful. These wraps stick to themselves only and hold any part of your body firmly in place. It works great for broken or injured toes and keeps them immobilized until you can see a doctor.

Read more

For any athlete and an active person, there needs to be a product that will come in handy in an emergency. These toe wraps are that kind of product. The roll is compact enough so that it can be carried in a bag, purse, or a first aid kit so that you will always have it handy. This bandage is very strong so that you do not need to worry about it getting loose or coming off.

The fabric of these toe wraps is soft and elastic which makes it able to perfectly hug your toes or any other part of your body. It will be comfortable against your skin. It does not require any clips that could hurt your skin. Each roll is two inches wide and there are twelve of them in one package. The fabric is easy to cut simply by using scissors so that you can do it by yourself in an emergency.

These bandages can be used for all sorts of pain, sprains, or injuries. Their use is not limited to broken toes. They are widely applicable and will prove to be very helpful and come in handy someday. The great thing about this fabric is that it is porous and will not cause your skin to overheat when it comes in contact with it. Each roll is carefully and individually packaged and even one package will be able to last you for a very long time!

2. Bodyprox

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
98.2
Bodyprox Broken Toe Wraps
Amazon Link
Application
98
Breathability
97
Compression
99
Effectiveness
99
Protection
98
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$9.99
Pros:

Reuseable ice packet

Adjustable velcro straps

Can be used hot or cold

Non-toxic gel

Cons:

No protection from direct cold

This awesome product from the Bodyprox company is everything that you need to keep your arms, legs, feet, or ankles secure and comfortable if they happen to be injured. If you practice any sport or martial art, an injury or a sprain is bound to happen one way or another. That is why everyone should have this product handy. It is not exactly one of the toe wraps, but thanks to its versatility it can be used to alleviate pain even from a broken toe.

Read more

This compression wrap is very flexible and has an ice gel pack that keeps the injured area cool and alleviates pain effectively. The gel pack is reusable. It can be frozen, heated or microwaved without losing its effectiveness or consistency. This wrap has adjustable straps and it can be quickly loosened or tightened, depending on your needs and the affected body part.

These compression wraps are ideal for various sprains and injury. They can relieve soreness, pain, and even arthritis and carpal tunnel pain. It is able to increase circulation and alleviate inflammation and swelling. The company offers a full money-back guarantee because they are very confident in the quality and effectiveness of their product. Even though it is a bit big to only accommodate a broken toe, this wrap can help to relieve some pain and make you comfortable until you can see a doctor.

3. Beaut (TM)

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
98
Beaut (TM) Broken Toe Wraps
Amazon Link
Application
99
Breathability
98
Compression
98
Effectiveness
98
Protection
97
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$8.99
Pros:

Easy to use

Stays in place

Washable

Very comfortable

Cons:

May come undone while walking

These broken toe straps are originally designed to be used as toe straighteners, but people have quickly found another use for this very helpful product. They are perfectly able to keep your toes still and in place if one of them happens to be broken, which is imminent if you are an athlete or an avid martial artist. When it comes to that, these broken toe wraps are great to have handy because they can be used to quickly and efficiently immobilize the affected toe. They are very affordable and something that every athlete should have in their first-aid kit.

Read more

These toe wraps are essentially cushioned tapes that act as a splint. They work by wrapping your broken toe and the one next to it so that it can provide additional support and make the affected toe stay in the right position. The wrap is very comfortable and easily removable. It can even be washed and reused many times.

Putting this broken toe wrap is very easy. Simply wrap them around the affected toe and the one next to it and tighten them so that they are held securely in place and parallel to one another. Putting them on may cause some discomfort but it will be so quick that you will soon forget about it. The wraps will stay in place and will not get loose or fall off even while walking and moving. The great advantage over rigid splints is that you will still be able to move that foot, although a bit more carefully, while staying comfortable the entire time.

4. Zen Toes

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96.8
Zen Toes Broken Toe Wraps
Amazon Link
Application
97
Breathability
96
Compression
97
Effectiveness
98
Protection
96
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$9.99
Pros:

Easy to use

Washable

Reusable

Comfortable

Padded

Non-slip fabric

Cons:

Stretches after few uses

Zen Toes is a small, family-owned company that is based in Wisconsin. They strive to create the best toe wraps that will help with alleviating all kinds of pain and discomfort at very reasonable prices. Their broken toe wraps are a bit similar to the previous one on our list, but still so very different. These are made from a non-slip fabric that makes them easy to secure and to stay in place. In one package, you will receive four toe wraps that can be reused. This product represents one of the most effective ways to keep your toes immobilized quickly and safely.

Read more

These awesome toe wraps are very easy to put on and they stay in place even if you are moving. They can be adjusted to satisfy your needs and you can be sure that they will not slip at any point of your day. They work by essentially tying your broken toe to the one next to it so that it can act as a splint and keep the broken one fixed in place.

The bandages are cushioned and will provide great comfort to the wearer at all times, unlike the rigid splints that make it very uncomfortable to walk or stand. These toe wraps are easily washable and can be reused numerous times. They are very thin and very flexible which makes them amazingly easy to use. It is able to effectively alleviate pain and keep you feeling as comfortable as possible while you are waiting for your toe to heal properly.

5. Support Plus

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96.2
Support Plus Broken Toe Wraps
Amazon Link
Application
96
Breathability
95
Compression
97
Effectiveness
97
Protection
96
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$13.20
Pros:

Easy to use

Adjustable velcro strap

Gel pocket

Versatile

Fits on either foot

Cons:

Velcro may stick to socks

If you think that this product is the same as the previous one, then better look again. Even though it uses the same principle, this broken toe wrap is slightly different. It is a bit bigger, but the main difference is that this one has a soft gel wedge that is able to comfortably separate your toes and keep them cool and comfortable. They are easy to use and can even fit over the big toe, unlike many similar products. They are compact enough to be able to fit in a shoe so that you can go on normally with your life while waiting for your finger to heal properly.

Read more

These toe wraps are able to help with dealing with bunions, hammer toe, overlapping or broken toes. They have a variety of uses and are a great thing to have around the house or in a first-aid kit. They are very easy to put on and adjust by using a very helpful velcro strip. These wraps are placed over three fingers, with the broken or injured one in the middle so that it can stay in place even while walking or standing up.

Given that these wraps were not originally made for broken toes, they do work great in keeping them comfortably immobile. It is made so that it is very easy and almost pain-free to put on and to take off. The only problem may be the velcro strap because it may stick to the sock if you want to put it on. Other than this very minor setback, these toe wraps are a great and affordable way of keeping your toes in a correct and comfortable position without a problem or hassle.

6. Syshion

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.4
Syshion Toe Wraps
Amazon Link
Application
95
Breathability
93
Compression
95
Effectiveness
94
Protection
95
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$7.90
Pros:

Self-adherent

Do not stick to skin

Easy to use

No scissors needed

Elastic

Breathable

Cons:

May have a strong smell

Slips due to sweating

Here we have another self-adherent tape from Syshion. These broken toe wraps come in three different colors, beige, blue, and pink. The beige ones may blend in with your skin tone and be almost invisible, while the other two will make you look more fashionable. They are very strong and elastic and will not break easily even if they are pulled. They will stick only to themselves and not on any other surface such as your skin, socks, or shoes. They are also easy to tear off without using any scissors.

Read more

These amazing toe wraps are made from polyurethane filament. The surface has a natural latex which is breathable and comfortable. These wraps will not cause your toes to sweat or give off an unpleasant smell. They can be used by the entire family, from children to the elderly because they are so easy to use, put on, and take off.

They can help with a variety of problems, such as, of course, a broken toe, sprains, swelling, or soreness. They can effectively alleviate pain and can be used to wrap any part of your body. What makes these toe wraps so great is their versatility and their ability to be used for more than one purpose. This product is something that every athlete and an active person should have in their first-aid kit.

7. Zen Toes

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94
Zen Toes Wraps
Amazon Link
Application
95
Breathability
94
Compression
93
Effectiveness
94
Protection
94
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$15.50
Pros:

Adhesive

Provides protection

Durable moleskin

Very affordable

Cons:

Stickiness may wear off

Here we have yet another product from the amazing, family-owned, Zen Toes company. This package consists of ten individual moleskin splints for the injuries of the big toe. It is a very simple product, but so helpful and above all, very affordable. These strips provide great support to your big toe and they are so easy to put on and adjust. They also provide great protection to your toe while keeping it securely in place while it heals. The material is very durable and strong.

Read more

These toe wraps have an adhesive surface that makes them cling to your foot easily and quickly. They will not slip off while you are moving or wearing your shoes. They provide excellent support to the big toe while also keeping it safe from injury. The moleskin, which the wraps are made from, is a material that is known to be very durable and strong, but also very comfortable. It is able to provide the necessary support in order to keep your toe straight and to help it heal quickly while providing you with great comfort and movement.

These toe wraps can be used by both men and women, young people and old, and on either foot. While wearing your strip you will feel much less pain and stops the toe from bending at the joint, helping it to heal much quicker.

8. Nexcare

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93
Nexcare
Amazon Link
Application
92
Breathability
93
Compression
94
Effectiveness
93
Protection
93
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$8.97
Pros:

Elastic

Self-adherent

Tan color

Lightweight

Breathable

Great support

Cons:

Contains latex

May be too thin

This self-adherent tape is specially made to be wrapped around the toes and fingers. It is very long but fairly thin in order to be able to be wrapped around small body parts. The entire length of the tape is five yards, which is more than enough to last for a very long time and be used by the entire family. It is a great thing to have at your home or in your first-aid kit, just in case someone needs it. These broken toe wraps come only in the tan color which is great if you do not want yours to be obvious.

Read more

The toe wraps are very lightweight, comfortable, and breathable. They will not cause your skin to overheat, give off unpleasant smells or flare-up in a rash in the wrapped place. It has many uses, only one of them being support for a broken toe. It can also be used to secure and protect sprains and compresses an injured area.

These wraps are very easy to use and to put on. They will not get loose or slip suddenly but will stay securely in place no matter what you are doing. It is very elastic, which means that it will hardly break even if it is being stretched on purpose. No adhesive products or pins are needed to keep this product in place. Those only irritate the skin and make the product much more difficult to wear for long periods of time. These great toe wraps, on the other hand, can attach only to themselves, which makes them worth every penny.

9. Point Products

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92
3-Point Products
Amazon Link
Application
92
Breathability
91
Compression
93
Effectiveness
92
Protection
92
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$15.99
Pros:

Easy to put on

Very comfortable

Pack of five

One-hand application

Foam lining

Cons:

Velcro wears out quickly

The 3-Point Product Buddy Loops easily and comfortably hold fingers and toes and are a great broken toe wrap solution for buddy taping. They are designed to provide a lot of support and at the same time be stretchy enough to not restrict your movement too much. You can wear them all day without ever feeling uncomfortable or irritated by them because they are not made from your common stiff Velcro. The material of these broken toe wraps is medical grade neoprene with a really soft and pleasant texture.

Read more

This product comes in a five-pack so you can always have a fresh one ready in your gym bag if one gets sweaty or dirty. Medical grade neoprene is also quite breathable and washable. These toe wraps can be used in different orientations depending if you want space and padding between your toes or not thus eliminating the need for much less comfortable solutions such as tape or hook & loop straps.

Being very sturdy, these toe wraps stay in place even during high energy exercises and practices. If you need comfortable, reusable and adjustable toe wraps 3-Point product buddy loops are more than a great choice, they are a phenomenal decision.

10. Ever Ready First Aid

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.6
Ever Ready First Aid
Amazon Link
Application
93
Breathability
91
Compression
92
Effectiveness
91
Protection
91
best offer for today
Amazon Link
$24.95
Pros:

Self-adhesive

Pack of twelve

Very affordable

Great support

Elastic

Cons:

May not stick well

Ever Ready First Aid self-adherent bandages are a good choice and can be easily used as toe wraps. They come in an individually wrapped pack of twelve with each bandage being five yards long and ideal for wrapping any and all appendages. This product will stick to itself perfectly but will not stick to your skin or hair allowing for quick, easy and pain-free removal. These toe wraps are engineered to be anti-slip and offer a lot of support for your toes even when you are sweaty and slippery letting you avoid pins and clips to hold them in place.

Read more

Designed from great stretchy and breathable material these toe wraps can also be torn by hand so you don't have to carry scissors in your gym bag and still make a new wrap in seconds. Hypoallergenic and latex-free, this product also won't irritate your skin or chaff it at all.

While providing excellent support these toe wraps will not hinder your movement thanks to a patented material mix that offers tons of support while letting you move freely. If you require on the spot toe wraps that will do their job without any compromises, then look no further, this is the product for you.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Application

The application of the toe wraps plays an important role in choosing which one to get. If the wrap that you have chosen is a bit difficult to put on, then it is not worth anything to you and it instantly loses value. The easy application is very important. The wraps need to be easy to put on and to take off without causing your toe more pain or discomfort. The toe wraps also need to be able to stay in place even while you are moving, to make sure that your toe is properly immobilized. If it ends up moving easily, that movement can seriously impede its healing progress and speed.

Breathability

Breathability means less sweat

Why is breathability so important with these broken toe wraps? Well, we are here to tell you. Even though it does not seem that important as they do not cover a lot of the surface of the skin, an unbreathable wrap can still cause your skin to become inflamed, overheated, and can start giving off unpleasant odors, and it can even cause a rash.

For all of these reasons, it is always better to make sure that your wrap is breathable and it will automatically be more comfortable to wear. When you have a broken toe, it can take a couple of weeks to heal, and you will definitely want to wear something that will not cause you any discomfort whatsoever. Luckily, most of the toe wraps that we have included in our list are made from breathable materials, all you need to do is choose the one that you like the most.

Compression

Along with providing proper support for your toes, it is also important that your toe wraps are able to provide enough compression. That way you will be certain that your toe is held properly and immobilized in the proper position. The compression can also alleviate pain and swelling and even improve your circulation. If your wrap offers good compression, you will certainly feel the difference and it will make the time that you need to wear it much more pleasant and comfortable.

Effectiveness

How do you know if a product is effective? Well, any product is effective if it does what it is supposed to do and if you can see or feel the benefits that are promised. When it comes to these broken toe wraps, you will know if they are effective if they are able to keep your toes properly immobilized, stop them from moving, alleviating pain and making it more comfortable for you to stand or walk. If your wrap fails to do any of those things, you can safely consider it ineffective and stop wasting your time with it, and get a different, better one instead.

Protection

The main job and purpose of these broken toe wraps is to keep your toes or fingers held securely in place and not allow them to move or bend at the joint. In one word, their main job is the protection of the affected toe. That is why this may just be one of the most important aspects of these kinds of products.

The wraps are supposed to keep your toes in place while also protecting them and keeping them safe from further injury. A lot of the products on our list can be worn comfortably while also wearing shoes and socks. This makes them very easy to use and comfortable to wear, and you will be able to go on with your day without worrying about anything.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
#1
ico Application
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#2
ico Breathability
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#3
ico Compression
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#4
ico Effectiveness
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#5
ico Protection
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
expert tips icon
Not too tight!

Whatever you do, make sure that your toe wraps are not wrapped too tightly. You will want to wrap them around your broken toe carefully and tightly, but not too tightly as that can have completely different results than intended. So, to sum up, make sure that your toes are wrapped tightly enough to prevent them from moving but do not tie them too tightly or they can get uncomfortable and may impede your healing process.

Comfort is the key!

Whichever product you decide to get, always make sure that it will be comfortable to wear. Pay attention to its breathability, the type of material used and its softness, and its elasticity. All of these aspects will determine if broken toe wraps will be comfortable to wear for longer periods of time. This is important because nobody will want to or endure wearing something that causes them to itch, makes their skin overheated or impedes the movement of the rest of the foot. Search carefully for the best materials that will keep your toes sit tight and enjoy the healing process.

Other Factors to Consider

Bottom Line

The broken toe wraps are a wonderful and simple product that is designed to hold your toe in place if it happens to get broken or fractured. Instead of using only rigid splints that are inherently uncomfortable and can impede the movement of the entire foot, and even stop you from being able to stand, using these wraps has never been easier. They usually come in the form of duct tape and are mostly self- adhesive. This means that they are able to cling to themselves and do not require any pin or adhesive product that can irritate or injure the skin.

Broken toe wraps come in all shapes and sizes, not only the one that we have just described. They do not need to be made specifically for that. A lot of these products are very versatile and can be repurposed for whatever you need them to do. Some of the items on our list, for example, are used for treating bunions but are also great at immobilizing and holding toes in place in the case of a fracture.

Frequently Asked Questions

q: Are the broken toe wraps comfortable?

a:

The answer to that question will usually depend on the type of the wrap and the material that was used to make it. Most of the items here on our list are made from very breathable materials, which makes them very comfortable to wear. The companies are greatly aware that these products are something that will be worn for a couple of weeks and do their best to make their wraps and other items as easy to wear and as comfortable as possible.

q: Can they be used by children?

a:

Yes, all of the products here on our list can be used by both children and adults. They are easily adjustable and will be able to be adjusted to the size that you need.

q: Can you shower with the wraps on?

a:

Technically, you can safely take a shower with broken toe straps on. They are made from different materials so different wraps will not behave in the same way when they become wet. It may be much easier to take them off and put them back on and save yourself the effort of getting the soap out of the fabric. Some of them may be thick and they may not dry very quickly.

q: Are these protective?

a:

When breaking a toe we need to keep the break immobilized so that the bones can gradually and correctly knit together while aligned. Toe wraps play an important part in this because they do immobilize the toes so that they the bones stay in alignment. This means when the two broken bone part knit together, they should be straight and not off-angle.

q: How can I prevent breaking a toe bone?

a:

Fair question and the answer is to use common sense. If you are using your feet for kicking motions, you must develop skills to ensure the kick impact is not taken fully by any toes in a way that puts stress on the toe bones. While training in martial arts, asl your instructor for tips on protecting your toes during close contact training or working on heavy bags.

Sources

  1. John P. Cunha, Broken Toe Definition and Facts, Article
  2. James Roland, Everything You Should Know About a Broken Toe, Informational
  3. Coastal Orthopedics Staff, How to Tape a Broken Toe, Blog
  4. The Emergency Clinic Staff, How to Tell the Difference Between a Sprained Toe and Broken Toe, Informational
  5. Medicine Plus Staff, Broken toe - self-care, Article